Appeals court rules that school officials had a right to ban anti-trans T-shirts
Not surprisingly, a federal appeals court has ruled against a Middleborough student who sued the school system after he was banned from wearing two T-shirts with anti-transgender messages. According to an article by Sawyer Smoot-Pollitt in Nemasket We…
Not surprisingly, a federal appeals court has ruled against a Middleborough student who sued the school system after he was banned from wearing two T-shirts with anti-transgender messages.
According to an article by Sawyer Smoot-Pollitt in Nemasket Week, Chief Judge David Barron, writing for the First Circuit Court of Appeals, ruled that school officials did not act "unreasonably in concluding that the shirt would be understood … in this middle school setting … to demean the identity of transgender and gender nonconforming students." John R. Ellement covered the story for The Boston Globe as well.
Earlier, Morrison lost in U.S. District Court. At this point, his only recourse would be an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court. Given the high court's lurch to the right, maybe his high-profile backers at the Massachusetts Family Institute, a religious-right organization, will give it a try.
As I've written previously, Liam Morrison, then a seventh-grader, was sent home from the Nichols Middle School twice in the spring of 2023 — the first time for wearing a T-shirt that read "There Are Only Two Genders" and, the second time, for amending that to "There Are (Censored) Genders."
This was not an easy call. At root, the First Amendment exists to protect unpopular speech, and Morrison's T-shirts were surely unpopular among his LGBTQ classmates and their allies. On balance, though, I think school officials and the courts have gotten it right.
As Judge Barron observes, the T-shirts' message was demeaning to trans students and dismissive of their very identity. By contrast, if a student wore a pro-transgender T-shirt, that would not represent any sort of threat or insult to non-trans students. In addition, the courts have ruled repeatedly that public school students' First Amendment rights are limited when they are on school property. The school handbook in Middleborough bans clothing that targets "groups based on race, ethnicity, gender identity, religious affiliation or any other classification."
For all these reasons, I've refrained from giving a New England Muzzle Award to Middleborough school officials, even though Morrison and his family no doubt believe they've been muzzled.
No comments:
Post a Comment